Spider-Man: Brand New Day Review

I'll admit I went into this one a little skeptical. Four Spider-Man movies in, a new director stepping in, a marketing campaign leaning hard on "loneliness" as a theme, and a box office narrative that had already declared this a record-breaker before anyone outside a press screening had even seen it. That's a lot of hype to live up to. Having actually watched it now, I can say the hype is mostly earned, though not for the reasons the trailers were selling me.

The numbers, because they're genuinely absurd

Let's get this out of the way first, because it's honestly wild. The film pulled in $72 million from Wednesday and Thursday previews alone, beating out Avengers: Endgame's previous record of $60 million. Then Friday happened: $168 million domestically, the single best day in box office history. Industry trackers are now projecting a $325-330 million opening weekend, which would land this as the second-biggest domestic opening ever, trailing only Endgame. For context, that's bigger than No Way Home, bigger than Infinity War, bigger than basically anything not directed by the Russo brothers in 2019. Sitting in a packed Thursday preview screening, you could genuinely feel that this wasn't just hype, people showed up.

What actually surprised me: the loneliness angle isn't just marketing

Here's what I wasn't expecting. The trailers sold "Peter Parker, alone" as a vibe, but the movie commits to it in a way that feels genuinely uncomfortable at points, in a good way. Peter has erased himself from the memories of everyone he loves, and the film doesn't rush to undo that. MJ doesn't remember him. Watching Zendaya play a version of MJ who has no idea who this guy swinging around the city actually is to her, while Holland has to sit with that, is a genuinely strange, sad thing to watch two people you know are married in real life perform. There's a moment where MJ, sensing something familiar in Peter, pulls his mask down just enough to kiss him, hoping it triggers something. It doesn't, not really, and the movie lets that land as a gut-punch rather than a tease for a happy reunion two scenes later. I wasn't expecting a Marvel movie to sit in that kind of ache for as long as this one does.

Tom Holland is doing genuinely different work here

I've liked Holland in this role from the start, but he's been playing variations on "eager kid who happens to have spider powers" for four films now. This is the first time I've watched him play someone actually worn down. The glibness that's defined his Peter since Homecoming is mostly gone here, replaced by something more battle-hardened, and it's a better fit for him than I expected. Multiple critics have called this his best performance in the role, and having seen it, I agree, though I'd push back slightly on the idea that "better" always means "darker." What actually got me wasn't the brooding, it was small stuff, like a genuinely funny Fellowship of the Ring reference between Peter and Ned that reminded me these two are still, underneath everything, enormous nerds.

Where I actually disagreed with some of the other reviews

A few critics have flagged the amnesia plot as dramatically frustrating, arguing it freezes the Peter-MJ relationship into "a piece of sad irony" rather than letting it move forward. I get the complaint, and there were stretches in the middle where I felt that friction too, wanting the story to just let these two actually talk. But I think that frustration is partly the point. The film isn't interested in giving you the comfortable version of this reunion yet, it's setting up something for later films, and I was willing to sit with the discomfort because Holland and Zendaya sell every awkward, loaded pause between them so completely.

Sadie Sink's character is the film's best surprise

I won't spoil who she actually turns out to be, but her introduction plays like fury and manipulation, and by the midpoint reveals itself as something closer to Peter's own grief, just pointed in a different direction. It's the sharpest piece of writing in the film, and Sink makes the turn feel earned rather than a twist for its own sake.

So, was it worth the hype?

Genuinely, yes, though maybe not for the reason the marketing sold. This isn't the biggest action spectacle in the franchise, it's the most emotionally committed one, and the box office numbers suggest audiences are responding to exactly that, not just to another web-slinging set piece. If you've been following Holland's Peter since Homecoming, this is the version of him worth waiting for.

Frequently asked questions

Is Spider-Man: Brand New Day worth watching in theaters? Yes, both for the scale of the action and because there's a real emotional weight here that benefits from a full theatrical experience rather than a distracted living-room watch.

How does Brand New Day's opening compare to Avengers: Endgame? It's on pace to become the second-biggest domestic opening of all time, trailing only Endgame's $357.1 million.

Does MJ remember Peter in this movie? No, and the film builds real tension around that erased memory rather than resolving it quickly.

Who directed Spider-Man: Brand New Day? Destin Daniel Cretton, taking over from Jon Watts.

Looking for something else to watch this week?

Our movie recommendation quiz can help you find something matched to your mood, whether you want more high-stakes emotional drama or a complete change of pace.